skyscope: (Default)
[personal profile] skyscope

I actually liked this book.

re: ships

-I didn't really like Harry/Ginny before but I guess I've come to accept it.
-Ron/Hermoine in the middle was seemed just a little bit too confused.
-Why do I get a horrible Snape/Dumbledore vibe from this book.
-Snape/Lily ftw! This book is calling for Snape/Lily salad days! fic. I was so, so sad when Harry went into Snape's memories. And so touched that his Patronus was the same was Lily's. This gives a completely different scope to Snape throughout the whole series; it is so easy to see why he must hate Harry, who reminds him so much of James. Actually I kind of hate James now.
-Grey Lady/Baron was completely unexpected.
-Fleur/Bill was lovely. Although I have a really hard time imagining Fleur as a housewife. She seems a little too glamorous for that. I can only see her sitting on the sofa flicking her hair. And also, I can't imagine her family was so nice.

re: deaths

-Mad Eye's death at the beginning was just --! I was waiting for him to come back the whole book.
-Remus and Tonks came as a complete surprise. There are too many orphans in this world D:
-I understand that Fred's death was kind of necessary, because surely someone close to Harry had to die. But still.
-Dobby's death was also a shock.
-so basically I was surprised that she killed off so many of her characters.

re: characters

-Aberforth was teh awesome.
-Kreacher was too good to be real.
-Percy's sudden conversion made me happy, but it did seem a little too sudden and convenient.
-Neville has undergone a spectacular transformation, is all I can say. Slaying Nagini in one blow is rather a little too heroic for me to swallow. But his grandmother was seriously awesome.
-I thought Draco was better than that. D:
-Mr. and Mrs. Malfoy are A+ in caring for their son. This basically makes up for everything they've done since Philosopher's Stone.

re: writing

-There were some bits that dragged a little bit too much, mostly the bits when they were on the run and nothing was happening.
-The bit where they destroyed the diadum, I thought was a little too convenient.
-But the bit where Harry was walking to his death; I was really touched. I almost cried, which is quite remarkable for me since I don't think I've ever cried at a book before.
-Whatever happened to Snape's portrait? I totally need to see the scene where Harry and Snape have a very uncomfortable conversation, and Harry says an awkward Thank You.
-the epilogue: J.K Rowling doing a Tamora Pierce and naming her characters after dead people. I wonder if any of Harry and Ginny's kids are named after Fred? Personally I would hate to be called Albus, even I was named after the greatest wizard of all time but I guess there's no helping it. And basically Harry stole all the names for his kids, and Ron and Hermione had no one to name their kids after.
-I need fic about George without Fred, and how he goes on (or doesn't, if that's the way it is).
-Was full of Biblical parallels: Harry dying for the sake of everyone else, everyone now being protected from Voldemort ie. sin; his resurrection and triumph over evil. To satisfy the Christian audience, I wonder? But I didn't feel particularly happy about this, because Harry isn't exactly perfect himself. The scene where he Crucio'd the Carrow just made me feel sick.

September 2009


Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags